New York set up semi-final derby after beating Cincinnati in MLS play-offs
After sharing the opening two games of their best-of-three first round series, City and Cincinnati finished Saturday's decider deadlocked at 0-0 after 90 minutes.
That set up a nerve-jangling penalty shoot-out that was eventually won 6-5 by New York after Mitja Ilenic buried City's ninth spot-kick into the top corner.
Cincinnati goalkeeper Roman Celentano had single-handedly kept his team alive earlier in the shoot-out, denying what would have been match-winning spot-kicks from Thiago Martins and Kevin O'Toole.
But Cincinnati's luck ran out after New York goalkeeper Matthew Freese saved from Teenage Hadebe with his team's ninth kick.
That set up Ilenic for the chance to seal victory and the Slovenian made no mistake, coolly converting from the spot to send New York into an Eastern Conference semi-final derby clash against New York Red Bulls.
